I see attempts to make the UI better, but sometimes they fall rather flat. like they are in need a good UI person. For example, the timeiline trim mechanism in 2.6.4 is great. The 3.x beta mechanism is far less intuitive, it’s clunky, harder to use, less accurate, and more jerky.
Re the Enhancement adjustment types, the labels are incoherent… “Auto”, “Relative to Auto”, “Manual”. ANYTHING that’s not full auto is manual! That is, “Relative to Auto” is also “manual” because there are controls (not present in Auto) and you manually twiddle with them.
These would be more obvious labelled “Full auto”, “Auto adjust”, and “Fixed”. Because that’s what they do, especially via the values on the sliders that show when you choose the mode: -100/+100 with 0 in the middle for “Auto adjust”, and 0-100% for “Fixed”.
I would also argue that there’s plenty of UI room to present these three options as a single row of buttons, active one highlighted. That makes the entire MENTAL SCOPE of the three forms of control immediately obvious, and changing is ONE click. A dropdown is NOT natural UI furniture for changing the current display (show/hide sliders). Tabs or buttons are the natural UI furniture for changing UI subspace (ie what’s presented under it). Given one of the options (Full auto) doesn’t have subspace, I’d argue that a set of buttons would look better than a set of tabs, one of which would be empty.
With a dropdown, first you have to NOTICE it, because only one item is shown and it doesn’t stand out. THEN you have to DROP DOWN the menu to see what’s available. THEN you have to examine the options and form a mental picture of their relationship (because it’s a vertical list of text floating in space rather than a horizontal row of buttons naturally FRAMING or HEADING the slider space below). THEN, having formed a mental picture, you have to click the option you want, or to dismiss the dropdown.
So, three well-labelled, permanent buttons visually and mentally scopes the options, frames or heads the following content (if any), and allows option selection with one click. That’s it. Most of the hard work is done at the design stage rather than by 1000s of users at run time.
(And the “Fixed” option includes a button [ Suggest settings ] that parses a bit of the input clip and sets the sliders to some useful values.)