Selecting a mid-range GPU to replace my 2080ti

Hi I have both Topaz Ai and Topaz Video but that aside I have an RTX 2080ti (actually I have two of them but only use one…perhaps that second one gathering dust should go into my pc) and looking to improve performance. Is there a thread here somewhere that discusses the relative benefits of AMD vs NVIDIA and what kind of gains one can get generationally? For example I can get a relatively cheap RTX 5070 but could spend that same money on a used 3090 or even a 4080 for example. I do not have the budget to stretch to the world of the 5080 onwards for sure, so looking to maximise Topaz performance around the $1,000 mark. I do not play any games at all (sadly).

As I look more closely I can stretch to a new RTX 5070ti or a used 4080 Super. And it seems maybe to 5th generation will become better optimised down the road, if not so at the moment. The whole world of AMD of course I cannot figure out related to Topaz. I could buy TWO refurb RX7900 XTX cards for one RTX 5070ti

A used 4070 Ti Super or 4080 Super-Duper. :wink:

The 50-series has issues that are still unresolved.

2 Likes

There are no issues for me with 5070Ti and 5080.

Both cards are great for Topaz. If you’re on a tight budget, get 5070Ti.

1 Like

If you are on an actually tight budged, get a used Ti Super-Duper… :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

I also have no issue with my RTX5090

Maybe the issues show up mostly on PCIe 3.0 systems…

(RTX 5070 Ti Performance much worse than RTX 4070 Ti SUPER - #56 by j.tochtenhagen)

The 50-series PCI-bus reporting errors are known by Nvidia. But they might be just that. Reporting errors…

no, they do show up on all PCIe systems. In fact the standard RTX 4070 on my PCIx 3.0 system is as fast as the RTX 5070 Ti on my PCIe 5.0 systems (B650, X670 and X870 tested) using specific Topaz presets, depending on which post processing methods are used. Using my preset posted in another threat both have pretty much equal performance, while the RTX 4070 Ti SUPER is significantly faster.

1 Like

Ok interesting, I also have a 4070Ti Super, what I observe is my 5090 is almost twice as fast…as it should be from the data. (Asus B850 Board with newest Firmware, also checked my gpu has 16 lanes). My 4070Ti Super is in a other PC with AM5 B650 Board.

from my obversation this depends on the Topaz setting. I have a specific Nyx3 setting, which shows the RTX 4070 Ti SUPER much faster than the RTX 5070 Ti. Would be very interesting to know the RTX 5090 performance using this preset.

(it’s the NyxNoise2)

Sample Files are also included.

1 Like

Ok NYX, my speed refers to Stalight. I’m in the office and may try this out later