Forum Design is Poor and Frustrating to Use for Me - V2

AIDON

I strongly beg to differ. And I find it highly offensive that you routinely close threads that don’t agree with your personal bias on what is productive . Particularly in light of the fact that there is an entire sub-forum here dedicated to site feedback…and yet you close threads on your whim. Highly unethical and I have experienced this numerous times on your end. That does not happen on ANY other forum that I participate in. We could do without the Napoleon complex.

The most popular photography forum on the internet has a traditional format (very much like m43) that is head and shoulders better than what we have here, your opinion notwithstanding.

So easy…

I have also conversed with a colleague here that is a software trainer and she agrees that the BB forum, in terms of organization, here is terrible.

Countdown to thread close…tick, tick, tick.

2 Likes

Nothing to do with personal bias, it’s a pointless post as the forum software used isn`t the forum software DP review uses.

Good observation. Yes, that is entirely the point. Whomever picked this software was severely lacking in qualifications. As someone else pointed out, this is one of the worst I have encountered across photo, software, motorcycles, you name it.

BTW, in my experience other forums do not have moderators that feel compelled to interject themselves into practically every post and arbitrarily decide when to close. That really shouldn’t be your job except in the case of egregious drift. If the “site feedback” forum is not the place to point out the short-comings of the forum software then where is?

3 Likes

It is often pointed out by moderators that these groups are user-user and not for support (true). Just pointing out that it wouldn’t necessarily have to be that way. Using this area and the FB groups (which do have TL employee participation) demonstrably leads to user confusion on where to ask what.

An example of good sub-group organization…which allows for both official and user-user input and a one-stop-shop.

Here is an example of frustration.

How and where do I find the latest official release of Gigapix 4.2.x ? I can find an earlier beta, but not the latest after spending 3-6 minutes searching every way I can think of (latest, newest, search function).

How and Where do I find the latest versions of all of the AI program official releases ? Or the latest beta versions ? A few months ago I was able to do this, but lately no luck.

The forum organization, to me at least, appears very disorganized and haphazard and therefore very, very frustrating in practice. Yes, I have seen posts from people who have no trouble at all, but that fact, unfortunately does not magically allow me to find what I’m looking for -hence the serious frustration.
Maybe all of us who complain about this are total morons ? Surprisingly, we don’t appear to be totally hopeless and dumb when dealing with other forums (like DPpreview, or just about any other web page).

Thanks for listening.

Beta is found in the Beta section, note that at this time there are no Beta applications.

All Official Releases are only downloaded from the Topaz Labs website, this is a user to user forum.

Anything you want to find in threads can be searched for with the search icon on the top right.

That doesn’t work well. I usually search a page with ctrl-f but there is some code running that captures that key preventing it from working (a browser page search dialog normally opens).

There is no way to save a forum web page to disk. I normally use .maff format (Mozilla archive plugin) to save a webpage to a file. This is the only site on the internet I’ve come across that it can’t save. I can’t even save a long image of a page. None of the capture plugins work.

Please consider changing the forum software to something proper like VBulletin.

I don’t seem to have any issues:

This is using Ctrl-F;

and you can save pages to your PC in HTML or mHTML format by Ctrl-S

You can also click the gear icon at the bottom and select Make personal message which will appear in your inbox:
image

For me ctrl-f only opens the forum search dialog which is mostly useless for me. Don’t worry about it. I’ll get over it.

Maybe with Internet Explorer or Chrome, saving can create a file. But try opening it. Does it display the saved page properly? I avoid those browsers for security and privacy reasons. I’m using Palemoon (supported Firefox fork) just to use the MAFF plugin as Mozilla decided to take out the API that made it function after version 56. MAFF just says “failed” in the downloads window.

Saving to html or mht doesn’t properly save any modern webpage because of all the scripting. That’s why MAFF was created. It strips out scripting that breaks offline viewing of a web page. But it appears the forum software works via scripting, and MAFF apparently can’t handle that. I can save vbulletin pages and all other sites on the internet. Even Facebook, Youtube, and Reddit save properly with MAFF (try those with the standard Save dialog…). Please consider changing to vbulletin or one of the many clones.

Ctrl-F opens Page find not the Forum find & Ctrl-S work fine in Chrome/Edge/Opera as does html & mhtml.